Customer Reviews (56)
  • Customer Reviews

(56)
4.267857142857142
Rating Breakdown
Rating Breakdown
5 Star
(rsSummary.count)
4 Star
(rsSummary.count)
3 Star
(rsSummary.count)
2 Star
(rsSummary.count)
1 Star
(rsSummary.count)

0% of reviewers recommend this product

Comfort
Style
Durability
Awesome looking - by , Oct 13, 2020
5/ 5 Stars
Super comfortable

Awesome looking

Oct 13, 2020
Super comfortable
Sperry's reply

Thrilled that you found the perfect pair! Thank you for sharing!

This shoe is great! - by , Sep 18, 2020
5/ 5 Stars
The shoes are great quality. They also fit true to size. I love the style. You will need to break them in as they are a bit firm to start. This is the same with all other Penny Loafers I’ve had.

This shoe is great!

Sep 18, 2020
The shoes are great quality. They also fit true to size. I love the style. You will need to break them in as they are a bit firm to start. This is the same with all other Penny Loafers I’ve had.
Sperry's reply

Thanks for your feedback! We're happy you like them!

Narrow Toe Box - by , Aug 28, 2020
2/ 5 Stars
Size 12 the toe box is way to pointy and narrow. I have a size 12 foot, not a wide foot but a full proportionate size 12 foot and this shoe is not designed for a full size forefoot, the "last" or sole print shown in the pictures is very disproportionate in larger sizes. That is the definition of lack of foresight in a sophomoric effort in shoe design.

Narrow Toe Box

Aug 28, 2020
Size 12 the toe box is way to pointy and narrow. I have a size 12 foot, not a wide foot but a full proportionate size 12 foot and this shoe is not designed for a full size forefoot, the "last" or sole print shown in the pictures is very disproportionate in larger sizes. That is the definition of lack of foresight in a sophomoric effort in shoe design.
Sperry's reply

We appreciate your feedback!

Worth it... - by , Aug 01, 2020
4/ 5 Stars
Buy these in a Sperry store, because you will need a new size from all your other shoes. They run LARGE. I love the shoe. No regrets. The quality is awesome. They definitely need a break in period. I treated them as boat shoes and wore them in the tub to mold them to my feet, remove the inserts if you try that. The shoes were a bit to pointy for my wide feet...keep nails trimmed. I would recommend this product, and will buy Sperry again!

Worth it...

Aug 01, 2020
Buy these in a Sperry store, because you will need a new size from all your other shoes. They run LARGE. I love the shoe. No regrets. The quality is awesome. They definitely need a break in period. I treated them as boat shoes and wore them in the tub to mold them to my feet, remove the inserts if you try that. The shoes were a bit to pointy for my wide feet...keep nails trimmed. I would recommend this product, and will buy Sperry again!
Sperry's reply

You deserve the best! Thanks for being a fan!

This product is gorgeous, comfortable, stylish, and of great quality. - by , Jul 02, 2020
5/ 5 Stars
Excellent, very good quality. Thank you

This product is gorgeous, comfortable, stylish, and of great quality.

Jul 02, 2020
Excellent, very good quality. Thank you
Sperry's reply

Quality products without sacrificing style and comfort!

Needs to be more durable/ like originally - by , Jun 15, 2020
3/ 5 Stars
What happened to the real non slip soles like the Bellingham line had? The ones now have very little slip protection and very thin.

Needs to be more durable/ like originally

Jun 15, 2020
What happened to the real non slip soles like the Bellingham line had? The ones now have very little slip protection and very thin.
Sperry's reply

We appreciate your feedback!

Best Shoes Ever - by , Jun 12, 2020
5/ 5 Stars
This is now my third pair of these. I have not found a better shoe for comfort, quality and style. These dress up or down. They feel like walking on a cloud, the fact that they are dress shoes aside. They are great value for all you get.

Best Shoes Ever

Jun 12, 2020
This is now my third pair of these. I have not found a better shoe for comfort, quality and style. These dress up or down. They feel like walking on a cloud, the fact that they are dress shoes aside. They are great value for all you get.
Sperry's reply

Sperry makes quality products without sacrificing style and comfort!

Great Shoes BUT ORDER AT LEAST 1/2 SIZE SMALLER - by , May 04, 2020
5/ 5 Stars
Loving these loafers. Comfortable right out of the box - not like the sebagos, which are profoundly rigid. Regarding SIZE, make sure to order at LEAST 1/2 SIZE SMALLER; I had initially purchased a size 7.5 after reading other reviews - I normally wear size 8 for other gold cup boat shoes - but had to return and size down again. Basically, if you usually like having some extra room in your boat shoes, go 1 size down. If your boat shoes are usually in that Goldilocks fit (i.e. there is no way you can put a finger behind your heel) then only go 1/2 size down.

Great Shoes BUT ORDER AT LEAST 1/2 SIZE SMALLER

May 04, 2020
Loving these loafers. Comfortable right out of the box - not like the sebagos, which are profoundly rigid. Regarding SIZE, make sure to order at LEAST 1/2 SIZE SMALLER; I had initially purchased a size 7.5 after reading other reviews - I normally wear size 8 for other gold cup boat shoes - but had to return and size down again. Basically, if you usually like having some extra room in your boat shoes, go 1 size down. If your boat shoes are usually in that Goldilocks fit (i.e. there is no way you can put a finger behind your heel) then only go 1/2 size down.
Sperry's reply

Thank you for your review. If you continue to have problems, please give the Sperry team a ring at 800.247.6575. We are here to help!

Perfect - by , Jan 21, 2020
5/ 5 Stars
Perfect shoe in quality, style, fit and durability.

Perfect

Jan 21, 2020
Perfect shoe in quality, style, fit and durability.
Sperry's reply

You can't go wrong with this classic style!

Good Transaction - by , Jan 17, 2020
5/ 5 Stars
I wear a size 9 wide in my dress shoes, which are not Sperry's, and a 9-1/2 wide in my Sperry Topsider. I originally ordered a 9-1/2 wide size for my Goldcup Penny Loafer because of the need for an extra half size in my Topsider, but found that in the loafer that size was too large. I returned the larger size, which was an easy process that only cost me a trip to the post office. I ordered the smaller size and the new shoes arrived in only a few days, which was sooner than I expected. I am very happy with the shoes and I am looking forward to wearing them. I have been looking for this exact type shoe for months but was not able to find it [regardless of manufacturer] in the various brick-and-mortar stores that I visited. I have been loath to order shoes over the Internet because of the inability to gauge size and quality. With this transaction, it was somewhat like trying on shoes in a store, but from a distance and [on the short side] was a process that took some more time, but on the positive side saved me from having to run all over town to visit stores that did not have what I wanted.

Good Transaction

Jan 17, 2020
I wear a size 9 wide in my dress shoes, which are not Sperry's, and a 9-1/2 wide in my Sperry Topsider. I originally ordered a 9-1/2 wide size for my Goldcup Penny Loafer because of the need for an extra half size in my Topsider, but found that in the loafer that size was too large. I returned the larger size, which was an easy process that only cost me a trip to the post office. I ordered the smaller size and the new shoes arrived in only a few days, which was sooner than I expected. I am very happy with the shoes and I am looking forward to wearing them. I have been looking for this exact type shoe for months but was not able to find it [regardless of manufacturer] in the various brick-and-mortar stores that I visited. I have been loath to order shoes over the Internet because of the inability to gauge size and quality. With this transaction, it was somewhat like trying on shoes in a store, but from a distance and [on the short side] was a process that took some more time, but on the positive side saved me from having to run all over town to visit stores that did not have what I wanted.
Sperry's reply

Thanks for taking the time to share!