Gold Cup Exeter Penny Loafer, Black, dynamic
$136.99 - $179.95
2019-09-18T13:29:14.019Z 2020-09-17T13:29:14.019Z USD 136.99
InStock
Ratings & Reviews (39)
(39)
0.8615384615384617
Rating Breakdown
Rating Breakdown
5 Star
(rsSummary.count)
4 Star
(rsSummary.count)
3 Star
(rsSummary.count)
2 Star
(rsSummary.count)
1 Star
(rsSummary.count)

0% of reviewers recommend this product

Comfort
Style
Durability
Won't buy it again - by , Jun 16, 2019
2/ 5 Stars
This shoe is said to have soft grain leather but nothing could be farther from the truth. It has such hard back curve that the skin got peeled off my achilles tendon by wearing it for a few hours.

Won't buy it again

Jun 16, 2019
This shoe is said to have soft grain leather but nothing could be farther from the truth. It has such hard back curve that the skin got peeled off my achilles tendon by wearing it for a few hours.
Sperry's reply

Hello Ahmed! We stand behind our products and we would love the opportunity to help. Please visit our ‘Contact Us’ page and fill out the Defective Product Form to start a warranty claim. If you need any assistance with the form, give the team a call at 800-247-6575.

Fits way too big - by , Aug 22, 2019
2/ 5 Stars
I was very excited for these shoes, and knowing Sperry tends to run large, I ordered a full size smaller than my typical size. However, these shoes were still far too large, by about another full size. I had to disappointingly return them and look for a more consistent fitting brand.

Fits way too big

Aug 22, 2019
I was very excited for these shoes, and knowing Sperry tends to run large, I ordered a full size smaller than my typical size. However, these shoes were still far too large, by about another full size. I had to disappointingly return them and look for a more consistent fitting brand.
Sperry's reply

We're sorry to hear about your experience with these. Give the team a ring at 800.247.6575, we are here to help!

DISAPPOINTED IN THIS SHOE - by , Aug 28, 2019
2/ 5 Stars
I was disappointed with the looks of this shoe. I really prefer the different style of the former Gold Cup Penny Loafer with the flatter soles.

DISAPPOINTED IN THIS SHOE

Aug 28, 2019
I was disappointed with the looks of this shoe. I really prefer the different style of the former Gold Cup Penny Loafer with the flatter soles.
not comfortable fit - by , Sep 03, 2019
2/ 5 Stars
Fit narrow by the toes and loose on the heal. really floppy in the heal. I usually wear a 10 and had to downsize to a 9. not comfortable.

not comfortable fit

Sep 03, 2019
Fit narrow by the toes and loose on the heal. really floppy in the heal. I usually wear a 10 and had to downsize to a 9. not comfortable.
Nice shoe, poor comfort - by , Aug 21, 2019
3/ 5 Stars
I have usually purchased Gold cups and I find this one doesn't meet the criteria for it. It is not very comfortable and the sole is pretty hard. Lacks arch support. It is about 1/4 inch larger than advertised size. Bought it hoping to replace some of my other penny loafers, but don't believe it will be of use. I found the Gold cup A/O 2eye titan from sperry a much better fit and comfortable wear. Sperry appears to have changed the gold cup sole, not sure why, since the prior ones were much more comfortable and had better arch supports.

Nice shoe, poor comfort

Aug 21, 2019
I have usually purchased Gold cups and I find this one doesn't meet the criteria for it. It is not very comfortable and the sole is pretty hard. Lacks arch support. It is about 1/4 inch larger than advertised size. Bought it hoping to replace some of my other penny loafers, but don't believe it will be of use. I found the Gold cup A/O 2eye titan from sperry a much better fit and comfortable wear. Sperry appears to have changed the gold cup sole, not sure why, since the prior ones were much more comfortable and had better arch supports.
Sperry's reply

Thank you for your review!

Love this shoe! - by , Aug 28, 2018
4/ 5 Stars
I love this shoe. The only reason I returned this was the sizing is off. It is 1/2 bigger. I am usually a size 11, but for this one I needed a size 10 1/2 which is still slightly large, but it is okay.

Love this shoe!

Aug 28, 2018
I love this shoe. The only reason I returned this was the sizing is off. It is 1/2 bigger. I am usually a size 11, but for this one I needed a size 10 1/2 which is still slightly large, but it is okay.
Nice but sizing runs large - by , Dec 03, 2018
4/ 5 Stars
I agree with the other reviews that this shoe runs larger both in length and width. I sized down 1/2 size from what I wear in the A/O Gold Cup boat shoe and like someone else said, there is probably still a 1/4 size of extra room in the shoe. The toe of the shoe is slightly pointed so it seems like that's where the extra length in the shoe is going. Putting an 11 of this shoe up against the sole of an 11.5 A/O, this loafer is probably 1/2 inch longer. So just keep that in mind when you order. The width of this shoe seems to run a bit wider than a standard medium, which is good for me because these have more structure than the A/O and probably wouldn't stretch out as much. Undecided if I'm going to keep this shoe because of how long it looks, but the quality and comfort are definitely there.

Nice but sizing runs large

Dec 03, 2018
I agree with the other reviews that this shoe runs larger both in length and width. I sized down 1/2 size from what I wear in the A/O Gold Cup boat shoe and like someone else said, there is probably still a 1/4 size of extra room in the shoe. The toe of the shoe is slightly pointed so it seems like that's where the extra length in the shoe is going. Putting an 11 of this shoe up against the sole of an 11.5 A/O, this loafer is probably 1/2 inch longer. So just keep that in mind when you order. The width of this shoe seems to run a bit wider than a standard medium, which is good for me because these have more structure than the A/O and probably wouldn't stretch out as much. Undecided if I'm going to keep this shoe because of how long it looks, but the quality and comfort are definitely there.
Sperry's reply

Thanks for your feedback! Give the team a ring at 800.247.6575, we are here to help!

Great quality. Great looking. - by , Apr 03, 2019
4/ 5 Stars
Bought for everyday office work wear. Exactly what I wanted. Just a little bigger than all of my other size 11 shoes. They are comfortable and great looking. Can wear with a suit, casual dress or jeans.

Great quality. Great looking.

Apr 03, 2019
Bought for everyday office work wear. Exactly what I wanted. Just a little bigger than all of my other size 11 shoes. They are comfortable and great looking. Can wear with a suit, casual dress or jeans.
Sperry's reply

Thanks for the great feedback!

Comfortable and good looking - by , May 19, 2019
4/ 5 Stars
Bought these for office wear and they are perfect. Formal enough for a suit but with a classic style. Nice leather and very comfortable.

Comfortable and good looking

May 19, 2019
Bought these for office wear and they are perfect. Formal enough for a suit but with a classic style. Nice leather and very comfortable.
Sperry's reply

Thanks for the great feedback!

Quality product. - by , May 27, 2019
4/ 5 Stars
Looks good and comfortable. Gold cup is always well made.

Quality product.

May 27, 2019
Looks good and comfortable. Gold cup is always well made.
Sperry's reply

Thanks Dr Dave!